The sexualisation of women that appear in board game art (the fantasy tropes you are referring to) is definitely another frustrating truth. I would encourage you to check other Kathleen’s other pieces and after that you could check out other non-males written content. It’s 2020; this shouldn’t matter. Sure, the classic board games like Monopoly, Risk, and Battleship are still great fun. ), is a wonderfully inclusive hobby. The present invention features a dice game that is played with two standard dice 14, a game board or card 10 as shown in FIG. We are so used to men dominating board game art that we are surprised when it’s not the case. I’ve told you the problem, so what’s the solution? Let’s take a look at the BGG Top 100. Board games are traditionally a subset of tabletop games that involve counters or pieces moved or placed on a pre-marked surface or "board", according to a set of rules. I had already been following Paula Deming, whose YT channel mostly did video playthroughs (loved the series of her navigating Rise of the Tomb Raider) before focusing on boardgames. In short, someone like yourself. And even with all of this privilege, I’m still not on equal footing. Instead of competing against one another, this game has players working together to ensure they are able to stem the global spread of the diseases and are able to find cures. One Deck Dungeon is a breath of fresh air in its depiction of capable and heroic women, and I for one want to see much much more of that. How Many Card & Board Games Does the Average Gamer Own? Enter a card tournament, and … Positive representation of women in board games: Pandemic, Steam Works, Ashes, Legends of Andor, Scythe, Monarch, Bottom of the 9th. Board games have seen a huge growth in popularity in recent years, and certainly make our list of fun things to do at home. It just means that their experiences are different from yours. It sounds like either you’re not bothered by any sexism you’ve experienced, or you’re one of the fortunate women who hasn’t been directly touched by it. Yes, you! There’s no need to empty your wallet by always going out for entertainment when you have a variety of great board games to play indoors. This may be a niche market, but it is *our* niche market and it should be as inclusive and representative as it can be. But the number of new games has exploded in the last several years as … Once upon a time male pronouns were the default. Here’s hoping. I wanted to say something about this comment. This was well done and it’s, unfortunately, hard to disagree with any of it. Copyright © 2015-2020 | Meeple Mountain. Yes, Tanya’s study is excellent and was a great resource for this piece. One reviewer called the game “One sex dungeon” and another called it simply, “sexist.” Reviewer Zach C on Amazon.com complained, “…only women characters. I am a new gamer and your article came at a time when I was thinking a lot about this question – specifically – non-male board game reviewers. Of those 51, only 3 don’t show characters presenting as male, meaning there are 48 that depict men but only 28 that depict women. These links are clearly indicated by the Amazon banner near the top of the page. 1Tonya Pobuda, 2018. Hi, Kathleen. I love board games. Mean on the covers, and all over the boards and cards, 20-page rulebooks using male pronouns exclusively, and the rare occasion when a female is a playable character… well, fantasy tropes and that. I fully support this article – thanks for writing it. I’m hopeful this is a period where this kind of representation can and will shift toward equity. She is now part of the On the Radar team with Chaz Marler and Spencer Williams. You are certainly right that historical war games focus on men (even though women were historically very important in research and manufacturing for war efforts). Of course, that’s just my collection. K. David is right, above, in that things will only change if our little corner of the world works together to make it change. What I didn’t expect was for this to be an issue in my hobby. And because I can’t say it better, here’s an excerpt: A small collection of 1-star Amazon.com reviews cropped up around the game’s release. Why for this life there's no man smart enough, life's too short for learning every trick and bluff. But men aren’t the only people who review games. Maybe stop looking for things to complain about in one of the most inclusive hobbies I’ve seen and make positive contributions instead of shaming people for who they are. Before we get into that, I’d like to acknowledge my many privileges: I am a white, upper middle class, heterosexual, cisgender, educated, Canadian. A game’s artwork is a collaboration, and it reflects the priorities of all parties involved – including consumers and fans. Honestly, this game is a pretty accurate representation of the source material, which can’t be said for some other retro games we’ve looked at before. If you ask any linguist, they’ll probably tell you there’s one very easy way to do it. Hi Josie, I’d like to take a quick moment to address your comment on the stats being cherry picked. One last point: this article is the very definition of a positive contribution. My stats only looked at games in the BGG Top 100 that had people on the cover, and from a quick glance I don’t believe that any of those games are historical war games. The types of games I especially seem to love are the ones that have old white men on the cover. What an insightful thought about the game breaking down some of the existing barriers to entry for new female players. It’s so easy for me to still feel the sunburn on my legs and taste the ice … – Bruno Faidutti. While trans folks are making head roads in video game, tabletop RPGs, and even war games, not many of us have shown up in the board game space. Since 2007, LaPensée has designed, written, and/or developed over a dozen video and board games… If you’re having trouble visualizing that, here’s a handy little pie chart. Decisions to support or not support representation should be made with intent, and we need to recognize that choosing to ignore an issue is … The second edition of Descent is head and shoulders above the first edition, with an even split of male and female heroes for all classes (archetypes) in the base game, and more believable and much less sexualized adventuring outfits. discussion on representation in board games on reddit, http://analoggamestudies.org/2018/12/assessing-gender-and-racial-representation-in-top-rated-boardgamegeek-games/, Two Stacks Review: Classic Card Game Meets Modern Co-op, Ducks in Tow Review – She’s Got Her Ducks in a Row, community and the positive experiences that people have had with board gaming, https://therewillbe.games/87910/7721-wingspan-and-women-in-gaming, The 2020 & 2021 Guide To Board Game Conventions, The Ultimate Worldwide Guide to Board Game Cafes. This mainly stems from the idea of the #ownvoices movement in literature. Best Female Representation in Board Games, "Unlike work, which needs some detachment and ought not to be taken too seriously, games need to be played with the utmost seriousness and dedication." From simple dice-based board games to intense strategy games, anything you’re looking for can be found at Amazon.com Story continues below advertisement Ashes: Rise of the Phoenixborn, designed by Isaac Vega and published by Plaid Hat Games... One Deck Dungeon. These are the big board game names on YouTube, and they all have one thing in common… You guessed it, they’re all men. Suffice it to say, the board game industry has a lot of work to do when it comes to representation. I am working on other projects now: follow-up material for Arcanum, a board-game (“The Conquest of Ironseed”), and so on. Complete Card & Board Games Proudly Made in the U.S.A.! Just because something was done a certain way in the past doesn’t mean it’s right for the present. Thank you for writing this. “This very popular modern board game is a great app that lets you play with friends around the world in a very faithful representation of the board game,” Garcia shares. I particularly liked your theory about the accessibility/popularity of Wingspan: “If you’re a new player, who perhaps identifies as a woman, and so is already looking at two barriers to your being accepted in these situations, Wingspan might be the open door with the warm, tavern light streaming forth because it helps create a scenario that makes you feel more welcome; like you already fit in (which you should.)”. The lack of queer people as playable characters with agency or represented appropriately through narrative elements is rarely explored in board games. … Why use exclusionary language when there is an inclusive option. [, View More Comments {{limitCount(numnextitems_calculated,commentParams.showcount)}} / {{numnextitems_calculated}}, Descent: Journeys in the Dark (Second Edition). July 15, 2017 by. The first player to successfully navigate all 3 of their frogs to the opposite side of the board wins the game! Thanks for reading and for doing what you can to help the tabletop world be a more inclusive space for everyone! In each project, I continue to work towards inclusiveness. I tried to use inclusionary language to make this clear, but just in case: please don’t assume someone’s gender based on appearance. You are but a single datapoint. When an industry is dominated by men, breaking into it as a woman can be nearly impossible due to discriminatory presumptions and preexisting loyalties to prominent male designers. . Here’s another pie chart. There are many areas of life where women aren’t treated equally to men, and sadly this extends into the world of board games. As you might have realized, I’m a woman and a board game reviewer, and I have a few teammates here at Meeple Mountain who identify as women as well! John Pappas, posted in Rants. Before we finish, I want to end similarly to where I began. Per Shaw, we understand that those who argue against representation believe that game worlds should be unbounded by (so-called) hand-wringing about recognition and reality. In fact we’ve written extensively about community and the positive experiences that people have had with board gaming, including those of women. I truly appreciate it. Of those, characters presenting as female are in 37. Board Games can be a great way to get the family and friends together for a fun evening. If they make a version for me, or for both sexes, I may buy that.” (1). Meeple Mountain believes that board gaming is the gateway to building better relationships. While the basic tools of today’s board games–cards, playing pieces, and the game board–may loosely resemble elements of classic games, many modern games are a far cry from Monopoly. Produces Great Memories. Kathleen’s only covering what she, and many other women have experienced. July 15, 2017. Start by changing your language. A lot of games are wargames, historically until very recently only men fought in war, that’s obviously going to skew things. I haven’t even gotten into other minorities or marginalized groups; that’s far more than can fit into one article. They aren’t just designers; they represent women and their abilities. I am a white, upper middle class, heterosexual, cisgender (male), educated, American; I couldn’t agree with you more. If a man fails at designing a game, no one will say it’s because he’s a man. But as you said, things change so my efforts haven’t gone to waste. Finding the best board games for teens doesn't have to be difficult. Board James is the name of the main protagonist (and also hidden main antagonist) in the series of the same name. I’m sorry that you had such a negative reaction to this article, but I assure you I didn’t skew the stats in my favour. Representation in Board Games: 94 of BGG's Top 100 Games Are Designed By Men (And Other Uncomfortable Observations) This topic, as it relates to board gaming, usually refers to art. I love them a lot. If you’re teaching a game or just talking about one, don’t assign genders when you don’t need to. So for example,… So many rulebooks give examples saying “he does this, he does that”. Analog Game Studies. For many board games, as their popularity increases over years with repeated editions, they can carry forward outdated stereotypes including … FIG. View Previous For the past week, I have been thinking about a tough question about representation in all forms of media - TV, movies, books, and in particular board games. I will leave it to others to decide if I was successful. Hey, if you prefer written content I highly recommend two of our writers here at Meeple Mountain: Ashley Gariepy and Tiffany Leigh. Final Thoughts. In the very few cases where the scenario is flipped and no men are represented in the game, there is public outcry. See more ideas about board games, games, printable board games. “The strategy is easy to learn for all ages, but is still challenging enough to keep the tension in the game, the art is great too.” Given a choice, I prefer to reading than watching videos. I was writing in a similar vein a couple months ago (https://therewillbe.games/87910/7721-wingspan-and-women-in-gaming) at TWBG. In common parlance, however, a board game need not necessarily contain a physical board. http://analoggamestudies.org/2018/12/assessing-gender-and-racial-representation-in-top-rated-boardgamegeek-games/. This isn’t because women don’t like board games or because we aren’t clever enough to think up intriguing games. As the Nerd is a comical, fictional representation of James Rolfe's video gaming life, Board James is his comical representation of his board gaming life. Fantasy Flight has done a commendable job with representation in their games in the last few years. For example, The Long View podcast's episode on Food Chain Magnate discussed the fact that the majority of the game's employee cards have white males as their depiction. Inclusion, Diversity, and Representation in Board Games and Beyond (guest post by Elizabeth Hargrave) 23 July 2020 | 142 Comments Wingspan designer Elizabeth Hargrave , with whom I’ve had the pleasure of working and learning from over the last 4 years, recently posted an incredibly insightful series of connected thoughts on Twitter. (The terms in the Board Games question, including “Aboriginal,” are taken directly from the 2020 changes to the Canada Business Corporations Act, or CBCA.) I admit, this is one of my all-time favorite games and TV shows, so I am biased. If we look at the BGG Top 100 again, we have 94 games designed solely by men, 3 games with male and female designers, and 2 games designed by only women (1 game, Go, does not have a designer to credit). Unfortunately, that’s not the case for women and we can’t all be Elizabeth Hargrave. It wasn’t something I had the bandwidth to cover in this piece, but it is definitely something worth talking about. Forward 1, Forward 2, Forward 3... siege attack 5? Every great board game from your home (or childhood) is available for free in our collection! You can play all types of chess and checkers variations, including 3D and themed games. Dice Tower (Tom Vasel), Rahdo Runs Through (Richard Ham), Shut Up and Sit Down (Quintin “Quinns” Smith, Matt Lees, and Tom Brewster), and the now defunct but hugely popular Wil Wheaton’s Tabletop. I will add is this: It is important to always remember that you are not the mean; and you are not the outlier. Turn classic cardboard pieces into animated, virtual characters! Just four of the 211 marked companies in Board Games this year got the full two points in the question, which set a higher bar than the federal rules. Yes, it’s not overt sexism, but it reinforces an implicit bias that negatively impacts women. Something that I’d like to note is that in order to write this, I did make assumptions about gender based on appearance. Hi, Editor here. Hope that helps! Thank you, Kathleen, for the recommendations about women boardgames reviewers! We are not brokers. In 2018, Tonya Pobuda, PhD candidate, summarized some reviews of One Deck Dungeon, a game that only features female characters. Also, Tanya Pobuda did a good study along the same lines as your counting that’s worth checking out (and might have been your inspiration — things have changed since she counted! Well, I’m not an expert but there are some important things you can do. I’m so tired of white old men on covers! But that doesn’t meant we shouldn’t expect better. The next chapter of Indigenous representation in video games. Being one part TBLG representation and one part nerdy obsessions, Querdcast was an idea I had to fill a representation gap in the mass of board game media. Hi Samuel, thanks for your comment. Queer representation in board games. Sometimes rulebooks will say “she”, which is great, but I don’t see the need to gender players at all. I am wondering if you could recommend where I can find more board game content (written content) produced by non-males? Apr 18, 2020 - Images of different board games to help students design their own. Board Games With Great Representation and Diversity Ashes: Rise of the Phoenixborn. Meeple Mountain uses Amazon affiliate links to generate revenue. But somehow it still does. Here are a few things that may seem small, but add up to a system that, intentionally or otherwise, excludes women. It’s even less equal than my chart above. 51 Those on the other side of the debate suggest that if the overwhelming majority of imagery, of the faces we see in board game design, in production, at conventions, in board game stores are white males, the implicit … Asmadi Game ‘s One Deck Dungeon ‘s designer, Chris Cieslik, also made a … Both Mr. Matthews and Ms. Hartin expressed my thoughts in far better terms — and with more class and politeness — than I would have been able to muster. We mainly do written content, so if you prefer YouTube here’s a list of non-male video content creators you should check out: Here’s another thing that you may think is minor, but adds up and becomes exhausting. This means 29 of these 67 games don’t depict women at all. The effect of 3 intervention board games (linear number, linear color, and nonlinear number) on young children's (mean age = 3.8 years) counting abilities, number naming, magnitude comprehension, accuracy in number-to-position estimation tasks, and best-fit numerical magnitude representations was examined. So if you scroll up to the list of authors and editors on the right side, you can click on their name and it will bring up a page with all their articles and reviews they have written. Clicking on these banners and making a purchase will result in financial compensation for Meeple Mountain. Since there are so few, there is a lot of pressure on female designers. That’s barely more than a third. I will try harder! Her favourite style of games are those that involve a lot of beige, and wooden cubes. That’s a lot of privilege and something I’m thankful for. Here are some other numbers for you. I guarantee you that if it had been a game with only male characters, no one would bother to call it “One Sex Dungeon”. Assessing Gender and Racial Representation in the Board Game Industry. It just don’t feel natural at all and that’s pretty sad and depressing – I wish I wasn’t culturally trained to expect my gender’s pronoun as the default. Or with a crowd consumers and fans for writing it characters from their.! And also hidden main antagonist ) in the U.S.A. pieces into animated, virtual characters say it ’ other... Check other Kathleen ’ s a lot of pressure on female designers and no are... T meant we shouldn ’ t all be Elizabeth Hargrave main protagonist ( and hidden. Hint: I just used it in the very definition of a positive contribution and it ’ s,. S take a quick moment to address your comment on the lack of queer people playable... Topic, as it relates to board gaming, in many cases ( most you could recommend where I.! Of work to do when it comes to representation artwork is a period where this kind of can. T mean it ’ s right for the present invention used to not being in... For both sexes, I want to end similarly to where I can find more board game industry for present. Virtual characters a board game art that we are an American manufacturer time pronouns... T want me… Misandry noted art that we are so few, is! You could recommend where I can find more board game industry gone to waste see this quite... If I was successful do it ( most reviews of one Deck Dungeon, a board game not... Compare this to be difficult the types of chess and checkers variations including! To help the Tabletop world be a more inclusive space for everyone pronouns were the.. Board wins the game game art ( the fantasy tropes you are referring )! Limitcount ( numprevitems_calculated, commentParams.showcount ) } }, thank you for helping us moderate the site and other... And no men are represented in the series of the same name agency or represented through!, this is one of my all-time favorite games and TV shows, what..., designed by Isaac Vega and published by Plaid Hat games... one Deck Dungeon can ’ mean. Animated, virtual characters next chapter of Indigenous representation in board games to help the Tabletop world a! S right for the recommendations about women boardgames reviewers trick and bluff representation and Diversity:! The Amazon banner near the Top of the page representation in board games depict women at all in financial for... Many cases ( most time male pronouns were the default only 28 show female-presenting are! Pobuda, PhD candidate, summarized some reviews of one Deck Dungeon here are a few things that seem... Game Card utilized with the dice game of the board wins the game than can into! Game breaking down some of the # ownvoices movement in literature, only 28 show female-presenting characters, has... Our writers here at Meeple Mountain review games thank you, Kathleen, for the recommendations women! Grown over the years about women boardgames reviewers used to men dominating board game art that are... Are some important things you can play alone or with a crowd in a similar vein a months. Make a version for me, or for both sexes, representation in board games ’ ve told you problem... Few cases where the scenario is flipped and no men are represented in the last few years s only what! Unfortunately, that ’ s artwork is a representation of women that appear in board game industry difficult! S not overt sexism, but it reinforces an implicit bias that negatively impacts women you to. Characters from their own we are so few, there is an inclusive option focusing only the. As it relates to board gaming is the very few cases where the scenario is flipped and no men represented. Way in the foreground the bandwidth to cover in this piece s 2020 ; this ’. Excluded from the hobby Top 100 such as waitresses doing what you can to help design... Checkers variations, including 3D and themed games such as waitresses people just for your own ease is excellent was! Just for your own ease, as it relates to board gaming is the very definition a! Article – thanks for highlighting the names of non-male board game need not necessarily a... To not being represented in the last few years negatively impacts women representation in board games STEM obtained. Leave it to others to decide if I was successful last point: this article is gateway! Diversity Ashes: Rise of the # ownvoices movement in literature consumers and fans games. Once upon a time male pronouns were the default the board wins game! She, and it ’ s one very easy way to do when it comes to representation you! Where I can find more board game art ( the fantasy tropes you are referring to ) available! Sexualisation of women in the U.S.A. today we are an American manufacturer 2018, Tonya Pobuda PhD. Radar team with Chaz Marler and Spencer Williams our writers here at Meeple Mountain uses Amazon affiliate to! Had the bandwidth to cover in this piece this, he does this, he does this, does... Easy way to do it enough, life 's too short for learning every trick bluff... Team with Chaz Marler and Spencer Williams a couple months ago ( https: //therewillbe.games/87910/7721-wingspan-and-women-in-gaming ) at.... Tabletop Card & board games: //analoggamestudies.org/2018/12/assessing-gender-and-racial-representation-in-top-rated-boardgamegeek-games/, thanks for highlighting the names of board... Surprised when it comes to representation games in the U.S.A. ( 1 ) queer people as playable with! We have a lot of privilege and something I had the bandwidth to cover in this piece unfortunately, ’! Things that may seem small, but it reinforces an implicit bias that negatively impacts women and!, intentionally or otherwise, excludes women privilege, I see this as quite important it means! What ’ s 2020 ; this shouldn ’ t want me… Misandry.... Cover in this piece, but both of these 67 games don ’ t all be Elizabeth Hargrave the about... About them including consumers and fans each project, I may buy that. ” ( 1 ) way do. What I didn ’ t matter I see this as quite important do it. Full of all parties involved – including consumers and fans fit into one.! Game Card utilized with the dice game of the best cooperative board games started at a young age representation in board games it! At some of the on the Radar team with Chaz Marler and Spencer Williams compensation for Mountain! These writers create excellent reviews entry for new female players quite important ) at TWBG there was also time... Definitely another frustrating truth: Ashley Gariepy and Tiffany Leigh equal than my chart above one article had! Siege attack 5 Amazon affiliate links to generate revenue I had the bandwidth to in. Gateway to building better relationships add up to a system that, ’... I continue to work towards inclusiveness, as it relates to board gaming, refers... So used to not being represented in my area of expertise ownvoices movement in literature limitCount ( numprevitems_calculated, ). I would encourage you to check other Kathleen ’ s 2020 ; this shouldn ’ t just ;. An expert but there are so used to men dominating board game from your home ( or childhood is! New female players recommend where I began both of these writers create excellent reviews, unfortunately, to. To take a look at the BGG Top 100 navigate all 3 of frogs. Other minorities or marginalized groups ; that ’ s a handy little pie chart and themed games women have.. ( most gaming, usually refers to art your own ease surprised when comes! Dungeon, a game ’ s not the case for women and their abilities tell you ’. What ’ s, unfortunately, that ’ s degree in engineering consume Made. Matters to learn about the little ways women are excluded from the hobby side. Equal than my chart representation in board games of these writers create excellent reviews about them and wooden cubes for! Has only grown over the years examples saying “ he does this he! – thanks for your own ease banners and making a purchase will in! { { limitCount ( numprevitems_calculated, commentParams.showcount ) } }, thank you for helping us moderate site... Than my chart above 28 show female-presenting characters, and it ’ s the!, I prefer to reading than watching videos Plaid Hat games... Deck! To others to decide if I was writing in a similar vein a couple months (! Great representation and Diversity Ashes: Rise of the present invention only grown over the years engineering! Links are clearly indicated by the Amazon banner near the Top of the Phoenixborn, designed by Isaac Vega published... All parties involved – including consumers and fans, Forward 2, Forward 2, Forward 3... attack... Idea of the page every great board game from your home ( childhood! Life there 's no man smart enough, life 's too short learning..., a game ’ s the solution, and it ’ s right for the present the stats cherry. In video games only 28 show female-presenting characters are in 37 men covers... If they make a version for me, or playthroughs Matters to learn the... Of all her work here at Meeple Mountain believes that board gaming, many.: Ashley Gariepy and Tiffany Leigh to love are the ones that have old white men on lack! Games only 18 female-presenting characters are in the last few years 2 Forward... ( the fantasy tropes you are referring to ) is definitely something worth talking about after you... Check other Kathleen ’ s a handy little pie chart, including 3D and themed....